2026 Fisting challenge

[NYCBill]

Re: inviting guys you cumdump for to also slip a hand in:

Let’s see what others say, but I’d advise against it. Fist topping is a skill, and if the guy fisting you doesn’t know what he’s doing, you could get hurt. 

For starters, it’s unlikely that a guy who came to breed you has clean, trimmed fingernails. So that’s a problem from the get-go. Even with gloves, you can feel untrimmed nails. 

If fisting isn’t his thing, then his teacher is likely porn, and fisting porn often showcases terrible technique. Too hard, too fast. Save getting fisted for guys who know what they’re doing.

If you know your breeder is also an experienced fister, that’s different. I love fisting my cum deep into a guy, and I’m sometimes a cameraman/doorman for a cumdump friend and after every few loads I fist it in. 

[NYCBill]

On 12/27/2025 at 3:13 AM, BritishCumdump said:

…but I have some regular fisters who know just how to use me, this challenge is about getting out there and meeting a lot more people and getting my hole destroyed 🥵

That suggests another goal. A list of guys (a subset of your regulars) who you want to get fisted by at least 10 times in the year. 

[bareback-flipflop]

2 hours ago, NYCBill said:

1/3 Manhole party: Nick F OBC Carl F JB O Julio MO O F Fu/Br…

 

How do you mark if he fisted you?

Or are you only a fister?

[bareback-flipflop]

2 hours ago, NYCBill said:

Re: inviting guys you cumdump for to also slip a hand in:

Let’s see what others say, but I’d advise against it. Fist topping is a skill, and if the guy fisting you doesn’t know what he’s doing, you could get hurt. 

For starters, it’s unlikely that a guy who came to breed you has clean, trimmed fingernails. So that’s a problem from the get-go. Even with gloves, you can feel untrimmed nails. 

If fisting isn’t his thing, then his teacher is likely porn, and fisting porn often showcases terrible technique. Too hard, too fast. Save getting fisted for guys who know what they’re doing.

If you know your breeder is also an experienced fister, that’s different. I love fisting my cum deep into a guy, and I’m sometimes a cameraman/doorman for a cumdump friend and after every few loads I fist it in. 

I fully agree with your comments on the top’s skills. 
Many people think that fisting is equal with pushing his fist inside. As an experienced fistee I can immediately feel if a fister is lame. Then I stop him immediately. 
But an unexperienced  fistee, especially if he’s high won’t recognise this. Even if this top doesn’t cause any injury it can be a bad experience which destroys the mood. 
So the fisters must play with huge responsibility and beginner fistees must be careful and find fisters whose skills are acknowledged or confirmed. 

[ff69]

On 1/4/2026 at 2:10 PM, NYCBill said:

Seconding the comment that ff parties are where you go for quantity, and a great way to meet new guys for future play at parties or elsewhere. For documentation, I keep a folded strip of paper and a pen in my sock, and log the name, social handle or other contact info if they’re new to me, and what we did (fist, fuck, oral, jack, make out, etc.). I then transfer that to a simple list in the notes app in my phone, a sample of which might look as follows:

1/3 Manhole party: Nick F OBC Carl F JB O Julio MO O F Fu/Br…

Abbreviate as you like. This tells me Nick I fisted and I gave oral (OB = oral bottom) to completion. Carl I fisted and jacked and he sucked me. Julio we made out, he sucked me, I fisted him, and I fucked and bred him. 
 

I put an asterisk next to the name if they’re new to me. 
 

I also had business cards printed up with my social handles and contact info. If there’s a guy I want to see again, I show it to him and slip it in his sock. That works well since most guys at the parties don’t carry anything to write with. 

Lucky Julio

[Carvalhal]

A good fisting top..listens and watches his pig for his cues to explore deeper and with more fingers. Good lube and hitting that prostrate to intensify the rush always gets a pig to open up. Progress should be slow, sleazy and careful. It’s intensely hot for both. 

Edited 12 hours ago by Carvalhal