I love BBRT and was amazed when I joined, I got a successful hook-up within minutes, after having tried all day and gotten really frustrated on A4A. I've tried just about everything but mostly just use BBRT and A4A. I've gotten around the BBRT community in my city a bit too much, there's not too many dudes left for me there, about 50 regulars and 200 beyond that, sort of a small little pool of people to choose from. The one thing I love about it is most people on there are forreal, looking for sex and not wanting to fuck around.
Craigslist is only really good for posting an ad seeking anonymous loads. You will get lots of emails and response. I just hate the trouble of finding a good 1 on 1 on there, its a lot of trouble exchanging pics and email, plus the site is NOT bb friendly, they take down a lot of ads and people flag stuff and I've even seen people "out" a bottom as poz with a new ad moments after they posted it.