Fantasies That Disappointed/surprised You

[topstud127]

Any fantasies that turned out to be disappointing? Conversely, anything you didn't anticipate liking as much as you did?

 

Shower sex is a no-go for me. Even in porn (mostly because of the horrible sound), I don't care for it.

I've had good experiences in a few gym showers, but overall, I wouldn't recommend "shower sex."

 

Mile high club doesn't interest me, lavatories are tiny, plus so much effort is going into making sure you aren't caught.

 

Otherwise, beautiful guys, often quite muscular, turning out to be subpar sex compared to how hot they are.

 

I enjoyed audiences more than I thought I would. Turns out, I don't mind as long as guys don't get hand-sy and try to force themselves in when they aren't invited. 

 

At a bathhouse, having a door open while fucking and flipping with the bf and having however many guys watching was super hot. Same for fucking in the sauna rooms and we've had 3 and 4 person rotation going in slings with a few people watching.

 

Once I start pressuring myself into cumming, I lose it, but as long as I'm focused on who I'm doing, its great.

 

[PozSlime]

Not disappointed, opposite in fact.

 

Fisting.

 

I was once very afraid of fisting and never thought I could take a mans hand in my hole until some old perv at the now long closed Man's World bath in Chicago stuck his hand up my poppered up, stoned hole and opened my eyes, among 'other' things.

 

That was the mid 90's and I have been hooked on FF ever since.

 

I consider FF my hottest fetish.

[kinkyslaveboy]

being  raped was better than i imagined

[fuckrogerbb]

I learned long ago that hot guys usually aren't that hot sexually and not hot guys are usually better sexually. I used to go to a sex club in Denver and I decided to do an experiment and just have sex with anyone. One Sunday afternoon I had 5 different guys fuck me and cum in me. Only one could be described as hot. It was an amazing experience. Changed me forever.

[averageslut48]

I am a guy, who says never "never". So I learned always new things during the years and did never regret it. Ther is almost anything, what i would refuse.

[Guest bbbearlover1]

Getting my hand into the pussy of my ex.  I used his Black dildo to open him up more, after I'd eaten his pussy, and then I just started pushing fingers up into him.  I turned my hand, and found that I had room for my thumb.  The sound he made, when I got my thumb in his pussy was music to my ears.  And when I turned my fist around in his pussy, the sounds he emitted were guttural in the best way.  Better than I ever expected.

[attwx]

Recently a top that i meet up with now and then froze a load of his cum and asked me to eat it.  it wasn't as hot as i thought it would be.  It was messy and extremely salty.  I thought I would have enjoyed that more.  Maybe if he had shoved in my hole and fucked me it would've been better.

 

A fantasy/sex-act that I enjoyed more than I thought I would was eating out an ass that wasn't particularly clean.  Sucking on a hot top's dirty ass, especially if he is hairy and verbal, is so much hotter than I would've thought.  

[Welshboi]

Always loved the idea of throat fucking, tried it with a guy who had a pretty thick cock a few times but tbh it wasn't as hot as I would of liked. It felt awkward and he wouldn't really pump like he would during anal, maybe it was just the guy was shit. I wanted it to be intense like his full body weight on top and fast until he cums.

One thing I did try with a guy was some pretty intense cbt and he literally hit my balls till I came without touching my cock, it was odd because at first it was painful and not nice but it suddenly became amazing, he would do a mix of fast and light and then hard and slow until the end where it was hard and fast and I just came from the intensity. was hard to find guys who would do it that rough :/

[not_sure_bb]

getting fucked in a sling with others watching turned out to be hotter than i thought it would be and thats saying something since id been dreaming of it for years

[subboy81]

mine was first time getting fucked bb,i had asked him to pull out, which he didnt, i liked it a lot more than i taught

[Jamie85]

One fantasy that I've done that was a dud, was my B/F calling me asking if I could get out of the house, bring my laptop and some porn.  I said yes to all and he told me he would pick me up in a half hour.  I got ready and he picked me up.  Seems he had managed to put together a :"four-some" as he put it.  Two other guys were going to meet us at the motel room.  I got excited.  Got there, showered and the first guy got there. They got ready and I was only wearing panties.  The other guy started out by sucking the B/F off which quickly led to the B/F starting to fuck him.  The second guy shows up just as they start.  He got naked and joined in quickly.  He's a bottom too it seemed.  I felt left out.  I was eventually invited in and ended up sucking a rather tiny, and by that, I mean 2 inch dick which didn't get hard at all.  By the end of this, the B/F had fucked them both with condoms.  The other two left and I finally got him to myself and did indeed get fucked bare as he had no more condoms.  That was the saving grace of the whole disaster.

 

As for the surprise, it was still with that same B/F.  I had sucked a few different guys off before I met him but I invited him back after our first encounter.  He returned and for nearly four years, every time he showed up, he fed me two loads of cum.  My favorite fantasy cum true and I'm scared that all good things cum to an end.  I hope not.

[chubbybear]

Have yet to experience a fantasy that disappointed me.

 

The one that surprised me was my first bareback experience. My boyfriend and I were on vacation and he "forgot" to pack condoms. We were horny so I let him fuck me bare but told him he had to pull out to cum. Somewhere in the middle of that fuck I tapped into my inner slut. He tried to pull out before he came but I said "Fuck it, you're going to cum in my ass and wrapped my legs around his back and held him inside me while he shot his load inside me. It was the hottest sex I ever had and was the end of my using condoms.

 

I always thought I would freak out if a man came inside me but it turned out to be quite the opposite -- I loved it and wanted to experience it on a regular basis. After we broke up I went back to safe sex for a while but my desire to take the load was too strong and so began my journey to becoming the total cumdump that I enjoy being to this day.  

[Guest Appletree]

Bald guys. I never ever consciously thought to myself that liked bald guys. But at a certain point I couldn't help but notice how many of the guys I hooked up with were bald or buzzed. And when it comes to sex at baths or other group scenes, being bald or buzzed gets you first class priority boarding on my ass.

[KindaBasic]

A few years ago I was disappointed with my brief experience of being "owned" by a dom top. I was chatting with this guy for months who had most of the gear and claimed to be an experienced "master". I was turned on by idea of my cock being caged and on speed dial, having my will slowly and systematically broken down until I was completely submissive to his will and whim. Though he had all the toys, after a handful of visits it quickly became apparent that he had neither the personality or experience to pull it off.

[Bottomhole]

I learned how painful gangbang was, when I was group fucked by (at least) 8 guys at Fickstutenmarkt in Berlin last year. It was still hot, but more in retrospect, esp because I was blindfolded and lost my poppers halfway through the experience. Many of the guys had piercings too, which was a new experience and probably added to the discomfort. When I finally had enough the last guy would not get off of me for a while too, and I was so exhausted that I didnt have the strength to push him away, he wouldn't stop till he came, which is kind of acceptable in this situation given the rules of the place. But boy did it hurt over the next few days. I was pushing out loads all night when I got back to my apartment