Do you guys think smaller dicks hurt more than bigger dicks?

[hedonist2018]

I’ve been in group play where I’ve noticed the bottom has a harder time taking my 5” cock (my girth isn’t too thick either) then whereas when he would bottom for a 7”+ inch cock, he took it without issue. They say bigger dicks are more spongy, and smaller dicks are more bony.

Is it the case for you bottoms as well? 

[Guest]

I got fucked by all types of penises, therefore I might disagree with you, I prefer girthy and thicker cocks eventhu they hurt the most. I like smaller ones, but what I don't like about them is they pump alot of air into my anus during anal intercourse. 

[Bttm2go]

Depends on the top. How he fucks. Generally I like an eight or nine inch cock the most. 

[theplayerking]

I think smaller dicks get harder so sometimes they can be more painful than a fatter dick that has a little bit of give to it. 

[lower_bucks_bottom]

I used to date a guy with a small thin cock. It would some times fee like he was poking me with a finger. 

[VersGuyAnon]

Small ones can hurt if they jab, or if they withdraw totally when fucking then miss the spot when going back in. 

[funpozbottom]

I think it's the position and angle of the penis. Instead of sliding along the rectum it can end up jabbing the side.  If a bottom is having trouble taking your cock, try a different position.

[cumdumpbln]

I think part of it can be that in order to take a large dick you have to really relax fully to let it in, whereas you can (unintentionally) hold some resistance to a smaller one and still get fucked, which can make it feel more 'jabby'. Might help to open a bottom up before fucking him.

[TravelGuy1956]

I agree with the "jabby" comments when the cock is thin.  Girth is best for me, even the shorter ones,  but longer is a bonus.

[polyglutton]

While it ultimately matters how the top is doing the action way more than the size does, I have only been hurt by a few smaller-than-average guys, but have never had lasting pain from hung guys. I think it's because a longer dick will fit in parallel to the angle of the rectum, but a shorter dick can end up hitting against the rectum walls at an acute angle if the top is not lined up right. 

[ultima6bb]

most of the time a smaller cock is even better. one day i met a hot guy with a great larger cock when cruising. it was great to suck but more painful in ass.

[Hole4u]

I have a few smaller guys hurt me with a smaller but really hard cock. I agree it may more be the angle than anything else.  Also my hole is purposely pretty loose these days so that might have something to do with it. 6-8 inches is the sweet spot. If they’re soft or hard I can take that size for hours. 
 

From time to time I get fucked by this dude that is somewhere between 11 and 12 inches and thick as hell. He uses a numbing lube and never lets me see his dick head on so it’s a guess. I base it off a 9 inch dildo I have and take no problem lol. I can take him through the second ring no problem but he thrusts really deep it hurts. Once I had to actually stop him but usually I can take it. 

[badjujuboy]

3 hours ago, TravelGuy1956 said:

I agree with the "jabby" comments when the cock is thin.  Girth is best for me, even the shorter ones,  but longer is a bonus.

The term “jabby” you mention nails it. I find thin cocks to do just that and prefer thicker ones but like you… bonus points for longer thick ones.

Edited March 17, 2023 by badjujuboy

[Bibttmmiami]

I haven’t noticed one hurting more than the other. But I do find smaller ducks to be more frustrating. It’s harder to get them in and keep them in. Also I don’t feel like they get in deep enough to really satisfy. 

[jmw003]

Not in my experience.