Opinion piece

[tallslenderguy]

i was going to put this in the Bigly thread, but see it's been closed.  Despite the frequent forays into snark, i thought there was some descent debate and discussion as well in that thread.  Ah well. Here's  an opinion piece i read this morning. i have not verified it's authenticity, but still have known enough people who have similar thoughts and feelings that i think it's a valid piece from a real person. Here's a partial excerpt with a link to the entire piece. 

"Commentary: I am a Mexican American who voted for Trump. No, I don’t hate myself

I’m a proud, first-generation, college-educated and gay Mexican American with undocumented family in the United States, including a mother who was previously deported to Mexico, and I experienced homelessness as a child. I am everything Democrats claim to support, right?

Wrong.

Democrats have accepted a progressive platform, ignoring decades worth of change and focusing on erroneous issues. They have built campaigns on a foundation of misleading airs and fake vibes.

Voting for Donald Trump does not make me racist, sexist, misogynistic, homophobic or any other “ist” and “ic” I’ve been called. I, along with more than half of the voting public in America, am sick of the self-righteous and label-obsessed left alienating us over differing opinions.

In her concession speech, Vice President Kamala Harris claimed to have built strong coalitions. What she did was the opposite. She did not motivate enough Black voters, Latino voters, Asian voters, Jewish voters, union voters and female voters to cast their ballots for her. Fewer women voted for Harris than they did Joe Biden, even with abortion being a top issue. To the very end, Harris ignored the data; she ignored what voters needed."

[think before following links] https://www.yahoo.com/news/commentary-am-mexican-american-voted-131500521.html?.tsrc=daily_mail&segment_id=DY_VTO_NTK_T2&ncid=crm_19908-1202929-20241115-0&bt_user_id=wU8przkQslG8%2BgQgEkTQ7DrYat2QR1cLn%2BDaVmZzxngIqJCvefWqmIQ%2BWVYABQxG&bt_ts=1731673543360

[Alexpdx]

I’m Latino and I’ve always been surprised by the Democratic party’s assumption that we are a reliable liberal demographic.  I’m very liberal personally, but my sense of my culture (Colombian - another bad assumption is that Latinos are a homogeneous group - there are a lot of cultural differences between countries) is that most Latino cultures skew conservative, whether as a response to failed attempts at communism in Latin America or the influence of the Roman Catholic Church. So I agree with the opinion piece to the extent it calls out this blind spot. 
 

What I don’t see this piece do, though, is address some of the genuinely horrific policies espoused by the right wing. It’s easy to point out the flaws in any party - no one has the answer for every problem this country faces. But there is a very real problem associated with the idea of rapidly deporting 1 million people. And ending support for Ukraine or a two state solution in Israel. Or a national abortion ban. Or the disassembly of the administrative state. I think the Trump voters I’ve talked (admittedly very few) seem to gloss over the impact these types of policies will have. I think they think it’s all just bluster. I suppose we’re about to find out. 

[verslut]

Quote

I’m a proud, first-generation, college-educated and gay Mexican American with undocumented family in the United States, including a mother who was previously deported to Mexico

He's clearly rooting for her to be deported again.

Quote

Voting for Donald Trump does not make me racist, sexist, misogynistic, homophobic or any other “ist” and “ic” I’ve been called. I, along with more than half of the voting public in America, am sick of the self-righteous and label-obsessed left alienating us over differing opinions.

Well you're gonna have to keep being sick of it. Because the ostracization will get worse from now on.

Quote

Seeing my undocumented family members, who have been in the U.S. for more than 20 years, work, pay taxes and buy their own homes with zero benefits, then watching millions of new migrants skip the line with government-funded help, only inflamed me and other Latinos like me. 

"My family members skipped the line to immigrate to America, but everyone else is the problem." What a joke, my dad immigrated legally when it was near-impossible for people from his country to get in.

Quote

Compare that to the Republican National Convention, where Trump had everyday people speak about experiences most of us worry about — the cost of groceries, safety, jobs and the border crisis.

Him in three months: "But Trump said suppliers wouldn't change their prices in response to tariffs, even though that's what they did last time. The price increases came out of nowhere!"

How do people get this stupid?

[BootmanLA]

On 11/15/2024 at 7:59 AM, tallslenderguy said:

Voting for Donald Trump does not make me racist, sexist, misogynistic, homophobic or any other “ist” and “ic” I’ve been called. I, along with more than half of the voting public in America, am sick of the self-righteous and label-obsessed left alienating us over differing opinions.

It may be perfectly true that you are not racist, sexist, misogynistic or homophobic at all. Kudos. But you are clearly not bothered by voting for someone who clearly is racist, sexist, misogynistic, and homophobic. Please tell me what the right adjective is for someone in your circumstance. I don't want to incorrectly label anyone.

[tallslenderguy]

3 hours ago, BootmanLA said:

It may be perfectly true that you are not racist, sexist, misogynistic or homophobic at all. Kudos. But you are clearly not bothered by voting for someone who clearly is racist, sexist, misogynistic, and homophobic. Please tell me what the right adjective is for someone in your circumstance. I don't want to incorrectly label anyone.

You do realize that the stuff in yellow and quotes is an excerpt from an article? The writer is not here to respond. 

[BootmanLA]

1 hour ago, tallslenderguy said:

You do realize that the stuff in yellow and quotes is an excerpt from an article? The writer is not here to respond. 

I do. But the thoughts implied in the quote bear addressing. If someone posted from an article that quoted Terra Cotta Hitler, and I wanted to respond to what the ice cold Cheeto was saying, I would quote Mango Mussolini and reply to it. Since my comment wasn't addressed to you - I have no reason to assume you're a bigot in the slightest - I'm pointing out to everyone the fact that Mr. Non-Bigot (who was cited in the piece you posted) is apparently clueless as to what his vote actually means. Not that he's likely to get the message. Until he's deported in some tragic "oh we didn't realize he was legally here, too bad" comedy of errors.