Have you ever had an ad answered by a DL guy that you know in real life?

[Guest CuriousDallas]

A couple of times I've been on chats on Kik with guys and it's gotten really specific sexually and was shocked when I recognized them from classes we'd taken together. One I knew had a GF admitted to taking anonymous dick understall in the campus bathrooms. I freaked and like an idiot stopped responding until I calmed down and realized how hot it was and that I wanted to fuck him that way. I showed my face and told him I wanted to and he was kinda freaked cause he thought I was dating one of my buds. We wound up meeting up and swapping loads understall...him taking my dick and me taking his. We'd message each other when we wanted it...apparently his GF has no idea he does this.

[Guest]

A couple months ago I woke up horny on a Sat morning and browsed on bbrt after being on here a while.  After a while this muscle daddy my age hit me up.  He had about 8 locked pics but only one body pic open that I could see,  I have about 8 pics all unlocked all the time and face showing in 2 or 3 of them.  So it's obvious who I am, and my lame SN just confirms who I am lol.  So this stud wants to know if I wanna fuck.  We are both vers and he tells me he's just been getting into getting fisted, assplay etc and wants a longer session.  I told him it sounds hot - will he unlock?  He said we know each other and thought it would be more fun if he just shows up.  I've just recently been getting into some anon stuff as bottom so I told him I'd even put my hood on and he could leave it on me the entire time or wait and take it off mid-fuck or anytime he wanted.  He was totally into that, but he said he'd be taking it off me since he wanted me to see who he was and wanted more than a pump n dump fuck anyway.  I figured from his hot body it was gonna be someone from my gym.

I then asked if he wanted to log off bbrt while we got ready and switch to text.  He said "no, we're in each others phones"   This was getting way more interesting, and I was getting even hornier to be a slut for this stud.  Of course I was trying to figure out who it was at this point.  I originally had someone in mind but a couple things about the stats and his distance away ruled him out.  So we stayed on bbrt and I gave him info for my place and told him I'd wait for him in a jock and eyeless FT hood on with eye covers so I can't see anything at all.  I stood in my living room and heard him walk in and start stripping.  I had my hands behind my back and didn't touch him.  He turned me around and bent me over to start slurping on my hole.  I reached back then and felt his muscled legs - big hard calves and solid quads.  He stood up and humped my ass so I could reach under and feel his huge nuts and fat dick.  I couldn't fucking wait to find out who this stud was and get his cock in me.  I did turn around and suck his cock wet though and felt him up more while I slathered his cock in spit.  He pulled me up on my feet and turned me around again and pressed that fat dick to my hole.  I wanted him to know how slutty I can be and pulled my ass open so he could slide in without any lube.  He was fucking me standing up for a min or two before he started messing with my hood to take the eye  covers off.  Once he was balls deep fucking me I turned my head so I could see who it was, and we both smiled.  He kept fucking me and asked if it was ok -  I said FUCK YES!

He actually was the guy I first suspected but his profile and distance away threw me off.  He was first from my gym, but became part of my circle of friends a few years earlier.  I had always wanted to play with him, but felt he was a little "out of my league" physically, then we became friends so nothing ever happened.  Then he got in a LTR with another beefy muscle dad.  He ended up having a falling out with a couple friends and was gone from the friend group but also attached and just doing his own couple things.  I always knew he was on bbrt earlier, and we were def the sluttier ones of the friend group, but never crossed the line.  That ended up being a 2 hour play session with tons of mutual ass play, toys, flip fucking, ass to mouth, me giving him his first full fist ever and both getting 2 orgasms.....both sober and on a late Sat morning    I'n not sure if it was hotter that we knew each other pretty well and wanted to show off what pigs we are for each other or what - it felt that way   He's hit me up a couple more times when his partner's out of town, but I haven't been able to play then.  It'll happen soon though.  Writing this makes me want it again soon.  I'm glad I put myself out there to someone I know!!

[travelingbi]

I use a fake first name when cruising on most web cruising sites as well as Craigslist/Doublelist. I've several times been hit up by co-workers, friends or neighbors. Since I don't like to deal with any drama by hooking up with people I know or work with, I like to stay anonymous until I'm sure who they are. 
I have however met a few of my neighbors through online ads. In all those cases, they are married, DL guys that I hook up with on occasion to service them. 
I did have one rather embarrassing situation at an Adult Bookstore Theater. The theater was really dark inside. As far as I could make out, there were about 4 guys in the theater. I quickly found a hot looking, muscular Hawaiian guy that had his cock out and stroking. I got between his legs and began to suck him. He soon was reaching behind me to feel my asshole. So, I quickly stood up, undid my belt and pants and pulled them to my ankles. I turned around. He spit on my hole and his cock and quickly slid up into me. He fucked me hard and deep. Soon the other 3 guys in the dark theater were standing around us, stroking their dicks as they watched us fuck. 
Even after my eyes had adjusted to the dark, I was still having difficulty seeing anything more than outlines of the others around me. One guy stepped up to my head and was stroking his cock in my face. I leaned down and sucked on his 7", thick cock as the Hawaiian guy continued to fuck me. The Hawaiian didn't take long before he was moaning and planting his load in my ass. He came, pulled out, pulled up his pants and was out of there very quickly. 
I dropped to my knees to continue sucking the guy in front of me. As I sucked him, my hands roamed over him. He was a bit heavy, but it all seemed to be pure, rock solid muscle. I reached up and tweaked his erect nipples as I sucked. I could see slightly that the other two guys were standing off to our side, kissing each other as they stroked each other's cocks. 
Soon, the muscle hunk began to groan and I tasted his salty cum fill my mouth. I sucked and swallowed every drop. Once it appeared that I had milked out every drop of him, I began to stand. He gave me both his hands to assist me up. As I stood, we came face to face. 
OMG! This was one of my co-workers that had the previous year taken an early retirement.  He had a wicked smile on his face as our eyes met. I was in shock. I panicked and quickly turned as I pulled up my pants and buckled up. I left the dark theatre in an instant. I just didn't know how to react to him?
This was a guy I had known and worked with for nearly 20 years and I had just sucked his cock. 
Now I kind of wish I'd stayed and talked to him. But, it was just too much of a shock at the moment. 

Edited July 8, 2019 by travelingbi

[jz48811]

A few times....  1. I once showed up to a guys house for an anonymous fuck. He was face down, ass in the air. As I'm fucking him he lifts his head a few times and I recognize him as the partner of a guy I know. I unloaded in his ass, pulled up my pants and headed out the door without him ever really turning around, though if he had he may not have recognized my face as we had only briefly met once. Later on I ran into the two of them together and his partner of course said to me, "Oh have you met _____ before?" Um, yeah...kinda. 2. I sucked off one of my student's dads in a porn arcade. Saw this stocky Hispanic guy come in, seemed familiar but couldn't place him. As he's heading into a booth I realize who it is and I at first freaked out and was ready to leave. (He hadn't recognized me, hadn't really looked my way.) But I went into the booth next two him, looked through the GH to check him out and he stuck his cock through immediately. Swallowed a nice dad load and he probably went home to his wife and kid, never knowing whose mouth he unloaded in. 3. Craziest thing was when I was on Manhunt chatting with a 19 year old, a thin smooth black guy from my area, face pic private but one pic was on hands and knees, ass spread. My face pic was also private. We chatted and he unlocked his face pic...former student I hadn't seen since he was a kid! Freaked me out and I was so glad he unlocked first! I thought long and hard (pun intended) about unlocking, but just couldn't do it. He has no idea he was showing off his hole and telling how much he wanted to get fucked by....his former teacher.

[coastalbender]

More of a reverse situation for me. I was at a bookstore years ago and sucked off an older man. It was good enough that we arranged me serving him regularly. His wife wouldn't do it for him. So, I was his little mouth toy. We'd meet, I'd open his pants and suck until he blew, then we'd go our separate ways.

I met him a few months later, after having sucked his dick 2-4 times a week for months, when he was introduced to me as a professor in another department where I was a student at the time.

We kept our suck arrangement for a while, afterwards, anyway.

[lovetobefucked]

Several times thats happened to me.  First time i had placed a post on CL and i was blindfolded, face down ass up and a guy came in the unlocked door and gave me a great hard fuck. As he was coming in my ass he slapped my ass, called me by name and said i was a good fuck.  Turned out he was my partner's friend and he had already bred my partner quite a few times in our bed. Another time i was stark naked getting fucked in an ABS and my boss walked in the open door.  Awkward! He didn't say anything but just dropped his drawers for me to suck him hard and then he replaced the guy behind me when he emptied a load in my ass and my boss rammed his cock into me and bred me. When he was done he slapped my ass really hard a couple times, leaving a good handprint, and called me a slut.  A week later he called me into his office, locked the door behind me and fucked me. I was only in my 20's and he was mid 40's.  

[lovetobefucked]

Another time i was on craigslist and answered a post. I sent my pics but didn't ask for any since i didn't care what he looked like as long as his cock was hard. Another anonymous encounter with me being blindfolded. A couple weeks later i was traveling with a co-worker to a conference. Company policy was to book 2 to a room for conferences.  Turned out we were in the same room. He took a shower when we got there and then walked out stark naked from the shower. Couldn't help staring at his nice cock ... he was definitely a shower! He stood in front of me and told me to suck it like i did a couple weeks ago. Told him i didnt know what he was talking about and he told me how i had sucked his cock and then he bred me. After that surprise the rest of the week was spent naked in the room and him breeding me multiple times a day and finding me other guys to fuck me.  When we got back home he fucked my cheating ass on a regular basis. 

Then there was the coworker i met at the bathhouse. He said "This us too weird". We spent some time talking and he watched me get bred a couple times but nothing ever happened between us. 

[Guest]

Yes, it was awkward; a co-worker responded to my profile, that I had up on A4A. I did not respond to him, due to the fact that he was not my type. When I went into work on Monday, he kept giving me a weird look, yet never confronted me. 

Although I do not catfish, thank god photos look slightly different than we do in real life. 

[Kimberley]

Yes on Grindr, a guy was sending me a text message that he would hook up for giving me a bare load, i saw his picture and realized it was the guy i knew from the neighborhood. i was in schock because i knew he have a girlfriend and  childeren, didn't knew at all that he was active in the gay scene. i had no face pic there so he wasn't knowing who i was. i just blocked him because i don't like him 

[Guest takingdeepanal]

Guy who taught at the elementary school that I went to in the early 80s. I recognised him - but he didn't recognise me. Let's just say that he was a pretty lousy top.

[UpstateNYexplorer]

Hit up a random blank profile on Grindr, He asked for a pic and I sent one. He said he knew who I was since we used to work together, didn't know that I liked guys, and wanted to see if I could figure out who he was. I did with ease since he was the only gay former co-worker I knew and I am kind of shocked at how open he is sexually since he comes off so...vanilla.

Edited October 22, 2021 by UpstateNYexplorer

[ItsCasey]

Yes I have!!

A while back when I lived in so cal I had placed a craigslist add.  Basically young btm looking for a hot top for nsa bb.

A guy chatted me up and we were around the same age and both lived in SD.  I asked him if he wanted to meet at this adult theater later that night, he said sure and we set the time.  I told him that I'd be in the back of the second theater where they played the bi movies (the first theater was straight ones).

I showed up early, bought my ticket and went inside.  Finally I see a tall skinny shadow come into the theater, he walks straight to the back and says hey.  I recognize that voice from somewhere but I'm not sure where.

I ask him how it's going and the next thing out of his mouth is "Casey, is that you?  It's Joey!!".  In a split second it all comes back to me, Joey was an old friend from junior high school!!

We chatted briefly while grabbing at each others hard ones.  He told me that he had wondered back then if I were gay but never asked because he didn't want to out himself.

He asked if I still wanted to mess around and I said sure and dropped my pants then bent over.

We did the deed, he finished and we walked out together.  We hooked up a few times after that but then sadly we went our separate ways.

[bisexualguy1978]

Many years ago, through a swinger hookup site. I wanted to hook up with a couple with the most perfect profile. When they send face pics I was sort of shocked, it was a co-worker I was working with daily, and the person you least expected it from (when is it not 😅), although he has a hot body and a hot wife that is picture-perfect (but also super boring). They were deep into BDSM and cuckolding, and both bisexual. 

I decided to not reply through the site but in person. The next day I started asking him how he felt about all the stuff they put in the profile and was noticeably getting anxious as he was quickly putting 1 and 1 together and understood I saw his profile.

I told him he shouldn’t be worried, as I was the one they were in contact with (although that didn’t make him less anxious). I asked him how he felt about that and started explaining my background, my experiences and what I’m into. At some point, he started to relax and we had a very good conversation, and he explained how they as a couple started sex dating. They only recently started involving other men in their play, and so far were quite disappointed, as many of the guys (they dated 5 guys at that time) told them they were bi but in the end only gave attention to his wife.

Considering he knew me, and listened to my experiences he, in the end, asked if I wanted to date them. This turned out to be a match in heaven. We had regular long sex dates  (2-3x times a month), lasting until the next morning and sleeping together) for many years. They were cumsluts like I am and had lots of bare play, also with other couples/guys present.

It stopped when she got pregnant, and not long after that he changed company, but recently came back into contact with them through SDC. 😊

[Treehugger]

I responded to a Squirt profile, told the guy I wanted to eat his ass. My profile was super piggy. Turned out I was hitting on the guy I work for. I was kinda pissed he was using a pic that was 15 years old. 

[PendragonSpirit]

Actually, yes. 

Well, let me qualify that. I didn't know him personally, but I knew of him.

Back in the good ol' days of Craigslist, I had posted an ad as a face-down/ass-up/no-strings cumdump. I got a response from a guy who had his real name attached to the email address. I knew I recognized the name, but couldn't quite figure out why. Finally, my curiosity got the better of me and I Google'd it and my area. Turns out the guy was/is the lead singer for a very popular local rock band, and married. 

I didn't let on that I knew who he was, of course, and we made all the usual arrangements. I have to say it was a little extra-hot knowing I was taking the load from a local celebrity. He fucked like a champ, too.